Sight & Sound’s greatest films poll 2012

May Adadol Ingawanij 

Academic, Centre for Research and Education, Arts and Media, University of Westminster

Thailand/UK

Voted in the critics’ poll

Voted for

Aguaespejo granadino1955José Val del Omar
Black Girl1965Ousmane Sembene
Brighter Summer Day, A1991Edward Yang
Evolution of a Filipino Family2004Lav Díaz
House of Trubnaia Square, The1928Boris Barnet
I Was Born, But…1932Ozu Yasujirô 
Manila by Night1981Ishmael Bernal
Night of Counting the Years, The1970Shadi Abdel Salam
Spirit of the Beehive, The1973Víctor Erice
Syndromes and a Century2006Apichatpong Weerasethakul

Comments

Most of the films on this list were made under conditions of repression or during moments of profound change. Creativity and political tumult are somehow linked – this we see time and again. What intrigues me is the way that filmmakers turn to the melodramatic and the experimental at such moments. Experimental films are richest when they draw on the resources of melodrama, and melodramatic films are at their most radical when they have an experimental charge. Two films on this list don’t fit this description so well. One is here because it doesn’t seem to belong to any time – such is its creativity. The other is here because it teaches us that life is very disappointing.